1:45pm
Details on Black Wednesday parties announced at Liar's Club, Buddha, Lava, darkroom and Bar Deville
Nobody’s quite sure which local spot served the first commercial beef sandwich back during the Depression—maybe Al’s #1, maybe Carm’s BBQ. “They’re all from that same period,” says beef expert Pat Scala, whose family’s meat-packing business has been supplying the raw ingredients for the city’s best beefs since 1925. There’s more consensus, however, on which stand serves the best Italian beef now: Johnnie’s in Elmwood Park is the champion, and since it’s also famous for short-tempered countermen, we’ve provided a lexicon of beef to help you place your order:
Combo
An Italian beef sandwich with a grilled sausage in the middle: the Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup of the Italian beef world.
Jus (pronounced “zhü”)
It’s the natural by-product of wet-roasted beef, drippings usually fortified with garlic, dried spices and a little broth.
Sweet, hot, mild
Your choice of simmered green peppers, or spicy or mild pickled giardinera. We recommend being bold and going for both.
Wet, juicy, soaked
A “wet” beef has a little jus spooned over the top; a “juicy” beef is dunked; a “soaked” beef is guaranteed to end up in your lap.
Practice your lingo with a standard order—“Gimme a juicy combo, with sweet and hot, and a small lemon ice”—and take it to Johnnie’s, or our other recommended spots.
Top five spots for Italian beef
1.Johnnie’s 7500 W North Ave, Elmwood Park (708-452-6000). The constant line around this cinder-block shack guarantees rapid beef turnover: You always get a sandwich at its peak potential. Bonus: The lemon ice is the perfect foil to a perfect sandwich.
2.Carm’s Beef Original 1801 S Wolf Rd, Hillside (708-449-0125). Co-owners Michael and Joseph Nebren still follow their grandfather’s recipe with delicious results: Rich jus flecked with spices, tender beef and better-than-average bread make this sammie a winner.
3.Al’s #1 Italian Beef 1079 W Taylor St (312-226-4017). Skip the franchises—the original on Taylor is the best. Al’s serves a greasy masterpiece with rich, crumbling beefy debris; spicy jus; and excellent hot peppers.
4. Patio 1503 W Taylor St (312-829-0454). Patio’s jus comes close to Al’s in beefy richness, but the meat itself—classic medium-rare roast beef—makes this sandwich stand apart.
5. Max’s Italian Beef5754 N Western Ave (773-989-8200). Max’s squeezes into our top five on the strength of its jus—bright red with paprika—and the plastic tubs of fiery giardinera that dot each table.
Plus:
The ’wich is back: Fast, easy, and—by definition—cheap, sandwiches are the ultimate bargain eats. We think our favorites (listed here in no particular order) are the greatest thing since sliced bread.
Saga of the sandwich: A brief history of the Earl’s famous invention.